Rosatti vs. Lorenzetti: the crack inside the Supreme Court

The activity on Thursday 12 was loaded with symbolism. The Supreme Court came out of courthouse to be present in Rosario and give a sign of support to judges and prosecutors who are constantly threatened by drug gangs. But that sign of unity is not so firm if you look at it with a magnifying glass: inside, the highest court has a crack that seems irrecoverable between Horacio Rosatti and Ricardo Lorenzetti.

The ministers from Santa Fe are in their sights. That is why, while Rosatti accumulates power behind the doors of the highest court, lorenzetti looking for become strong abroad, with public appearances and conversations with different social actors. Politics is not indifferent to them: the first, Kirchnerism made a march to kick him out; to the second, Elisa Carrio insists on cornering him with a political trial. They, without escaping courtly formalism, defend themselves.

Moving

Due to the crisis of drug violence that Rosario is experiencing, at some point there was speculation that the Court would arrive in that city in armored cars. It was the ministers themselves who considered the idea crazy. to the act of Association of Federal Judges of the Argentine Republic opened it Rosatti and Lorenzetti closed it. Power poles are measured everywhere. And every detail has a political reading.

the same week that Rosatti assumed as president of the Council of the Judiciary, Lorenzetti traveled to Mexico. In their environment they assure that the license was requested before knowing what the Court would decide. In any case, they deny the forms chosen by the highest court: “The idea was not to enter the Council that way, we thought it would be more consensual,” they reproached the new president.

Lorenzetti He was the only minister who did not accompany with his signature the decision of the supreme court to put into operation the Council of the Judiciary, which gave more power to his rival. The thing is Rosatti assumed as the president of the body that sanctions and removes judges.

“I did not agree to go back to the previous law, but it was the opinion of the majority,” Lorenzetti would later argue to make their differences clearyes “Once the decision has been made, it is what should be applied and we have to support it,” he completed in a strange first person plural. He was the only courtier on the opposite sidewalk.

“Here no attention is paid to those differences”, they lower the price of the fight in the corridors of the Palace of Justice. But the votes are counted: “It is 3 to 1 in almost everything,” they complete.

The president of the Court does not usually give interviews, however he reconsidered it in recent weeks after Lorenzetti made their differences public about the Council of the Judiciary: “If the others speak…”, he warned his team in allusion to his co-provincial. Then he backed off. He preferred media silence and a low profile, again.

designated

The course of events put the Court in the sights of politics. And the parties also chose their side. Kirchnerism targeted Rosatti: at the beginning of May referring to the front of all they marched to ask for the impeachment of the President of the Court, the main enemy. “He intends to take Council of the Judiciary the same as Macri appointed by finger, that he voted for himself to preside over the Court and that he issued the ruling that put him at the head of the body that appoints and removes judges”, none other than the Minister of Justice, Martín Soria, had pointed out (see box ).

From the other village, the political pressure was on Lorenzetti. Elisa Carrio expanded the complaint he had made years ago against the minister. “He is hitting the Court itself. He works for Cristina Kirchner) and what she is doing is an attempted coup d’etat”, indicated the co-founder of Cambiemos.

“They speak for political reasons. Institutionally that is irrelevant. as he spoke Boudou or Moyano (in the march against Corte), now Carrió does it”, Lorenzetti downplayed him in an interview on LN+.

After the show of unity against drug attacks in Rosario, the Court returned to its labyrinth. in the Palace of Justice the internal ones do not stop and the tension is always increasing.

Image gallery

e-planning ad

ttn-25