Amanda Seyfried didn’t win the prize in two categories – but people are still talking about her online.
Amanda Seyfried doesn’t exactly have a poker face. At the Golden Globe Awards on Sunday evening, January 11, 2026, that’s exactly what became the topic of conversation – and within hours, her facial expressions became a viral phenomenon. The actress was nominated twice, but came away empty-handed at the award ceremony. Their reactions were promptly analyzed on social media.
First defeat: The reaction to Michelle Williams’ victory
First, Seyfried was nominated for Best Actress in a Miniseries for “Long Bright River.” The competition included Claire Danes (“The Beast in Me”), Sarah Snook (“All Her Fault”), Rashida Jones (“Black Mirror”), Robin Wright (“The Girlfriend”) and Michelle Williams (“Dying for Sex”). Even before the winner’s name was mentioned, Amanda Seyfried began to applaud – a detail that many interpreted as a sign that she herself did not expect to win. When Michelle Williams was finally announced as the winner, the actress first showed a serious face, then a small smile. When she realized Williams wasn’t in the room, she commented dryly, “Oh, she’s not here.” The camera panned quickly.
This reaction to her competitor’s win went viral:
Second round, second grimace
But that’s not all: Seyfried was also nominated in the category of Best Actress in a Comedy or Musical, this time for “The Testament of Ann Lee”. Trailer here:
However, the award went to Rose Byrne for “If I Had Legs I’d Kick You.” The camera caught Seyfried’s reaction again – she grimaced, the corners of her mouth turned down. For many viewers, this was hilarious.
Editorial recommendations
Insider clears up criticism
However, others accused the actress of disrespecting Michelle Williams. An accusation that has now been clearly rejected. An alleged insider told the Daily Mail that Amanda Seyfried took the evening in a relaxed manner: she knew she would probably lose and had fun with it. She finds the resulting drama ridiculous, especially since her reactions were clearly meant in jest. Disrespect for fellow nominees is out of the question for her.
Speculation on TikTok about Seyfried’s reactions:
Fans still looked for explanations: Some suspected nervousness since Seyfried rarely attends major award shows. Others pointed to her long journey – she lives in seclusion with her family on a farm in the Hudson Valley near New York. Others even speculated that the reaction was a deliberate one, as the awarding of the prizes would be communicated to the nominees and winners in advance.
An established Hollywood great
One thing is certain: Amanda Seyfried has long been an established figure in Hollywood. Highlights from her filmography range from “Jennifer’s Body” to “Les Misérables” to “Mamma Mia!” In 2023 she won a Golden Globe and an Emmy for “The Dropout”, and in 2021 she was nominated for an Oscar for “Mank”. The fact that their defeats are now going viral shows one thing above all: Even a lost evening in the spotlight can create unforgettable moments.
___________________________________
Pre-order now: Exclusive 7-inch single “Baltimore”/“Stare” by Prince in MUSIKEXPRRESS 03/26
We are opening the year 2026 with a unique and extraordinary collaboration: on the occasion of the tenth anniversary of his death, ROLLING STONE and MUSIKEXPRESS are releasing two world-exclusive vinyl singles by Prince.
A few months before his death, the genius of the century had recorded two albums that once again show him in top form and will be re-released in the new year: “HITnRUN Phase I” and “Phase II”. These were to remain his last works. For “Phase I” he worked with singers such as Rita Ora and Lianne La Havas. “Phase II” shows him as a political observer of his time.
The March issue of MUSIKEXPRESS features a second world exclusive Prince single: “Baltimore” / “Stare”, two songs from HITnRUN Phase II. Prince wrote the ballad-like “Baltimore” under the impression of racist police violence in the USA. Both editions are also available HERE together in a bundle at the special price of EUR 19.90.
Included in delivery: MUSIKEXPRESS issue 03/2026 + exclusive Prince 7″ vinyl single