Recommendations of the Editorial team
The judge, who looks after the case of a man from Maryland, mistakenly after El Salvador has been deported again that the Trump government has to bring him back to the United States.
Kilmar Abrego Garcia is being deported with hundreds of other people deported from the USA in the Terrorism Health Anstalt (Cecot) captured in El Salvador. District judge Paula Xinis describes her as “one of the most notorious inhuman and most dangerous prisons in the world”. One in which humans are “held under the most inhumane and miserable conditions known in a prison system”.
“The officials had no arrest warrant and no legal basis to take him into custody. They only told him that his” status had changed “, wrote Xinis in her decision issued on Friday, that of Politico was viewed.
According to reports, Abrego Garcia was arrested in front of his son’s eyes
Abrego Garcia was arrested last month. He came to the United States from El Salvador because local gangs tried to recruit him and threatened him and his family. He was arrested in Maryland in 2019. But a judge granted him deportation protection because he would probably be targeted. His wife and five-year-old autistic son are both US citizens. According to reports, Abrego Garcia was arrested in front of his son.
Even officials from the Ministry of Homeland gave in an earlier court file To the fact that Abrego Garcia was sent to El Salvador last month due to an “administrative error”. Nevertheless, the Ministry of Justice has argued that Abrego Garcia cannot bring it back to the United States.
In an explanation on Friday, the press spokeswoman for the White House, Karoline Leavitt. “We suggest that the judge contacted President Bukele.”
As Xinis emphasized, the Ministry of Justice “has no evidence” for his claim that Abrego Garcia was a member of the MS-13 turn. In addition, according to Xinis, the government exposes it to a high risk of being targeted by the public name as a gang member. Since the facility as part of the cruelty of Cecot “brings together deliberately rival gang members”.
“He was a convicted MS-13 gang member without the right to be here”
The lawyers of Abrego Garcia told opposite The Atlanticthat the allegations that he was a gang member are wrong. They referred to police records, which show that the law enforcement agencies in 2019 could not find any reliable evidence of a connection to MS-13. They also pointed out that Abrego Garcia was neither convicted of a crime, nor was the law enforcement in connection with the law enforcement.
Vice President JD Vance did not prevent the obvious lack of evidence against Abrego Garcia from spreading false information about him. “He was a convicted MS-13 gang member without the right to be here,” he mistakenly claimed.
Xinis also refuted the argument of the Trump government that Abrego Garcia was in El Salvador. And therefore cannot be sent back to the USA.
“The defendants certainly do not want to say that they are the material and procedural protection regulations of the [bundesstaatlichen Einwanderungsgesetzes] Completely lifted in one fell swoop by having these people arrested in Cecot without an appeal, ”wrote Xinis.
“Rather, his detention seems to be completely lawless”
Xinis pointed out that Minister of Homeland Protection Minister Kristi Noem recently visited the Cecot. Where they In a bizarre video in front of dozens of detained men appeared that were captured in a large cell. In the video, she described the prison as “one of the tools in our toolbox that we will use”.
“As in any other contract facility, the accused can keep the power to secure their prisoners. And to transport. Neckro Garcia trapped. And they do this too,” wrote Xinis. And used the government’s own words to invalidate its argument.
Xinis also pointed out that the “legal basis of the government for the mass deportation of hundreds of people to El Salvador is still worryingly unclear”. However, she emphasized that the case of Abrego Garcia was “categorically different”. Because “there were no legal reasons for his arrest, detention or deportation”.
“Rather, his detention seems to be completely lawless,” she wrote.